Showing posts with label Rudolf Steiner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rudolf Steiner. Show all posts

Friday, May 20, 2016

Mix-Up: Economic, Political, and Cultural Life in Ancient Greece

Konstantinos Maleas, Detail, Landscape of Northern Greece, 1914

























SOME eighty-five generations or 2600 years ago, the poet-aristocrat Solon was asked by the citizens of Athens to propose social reforms in order to save the city-state from possible civil war.1  Tensions were high between the rich minority, the middle class, and the poor majority.2

A reform that Solon is perhaps most noted for ended one kind of fusion between political and economic life:  he made it illegal for an Athenian to be enslaved for failure to pay off a debt.3 The debtor's basic human rights, a fundamentally political matter, could no longer become mixed up with saleable economic values.

Before Solon, political power had informally been reserved mainly to the rich. Solon's reforms did not end that mix-up of the economic with the political; his new constitution merely moderated it by means of gradations.4 Under Solon's constitution, for example, if one's landholdings were extensive enough to render at least 500 bushels of produce annually, one was eligible to serve in any political office, including that of state treasurer.  Those whose acreage was sufficient only to produce 300-499 bushels could not serve as state treasurer but were eligible for all other positions including archon (leader) and high-level magistrate. Men whose land produced 200-299 bushels were eligible only for lower level offices.  Those finally who had no land or whose land produced fewer than 200 bushels were eligible only to attend an assembly that met regularly.  Women, resident aliens, and slaves were excluded from participation in the political system.

William Logsdail, Greek theater, Taormina, Sicily, c.1900















Thus Athenians fused economic with political life. That is shown not only by Solon's allocations of political power according to income levels, but by the Athenian use of non-Athenian slaves: slavery treats fundamental human political rights as economic commodities.

Today such fusions of political and economic life would of course be recognized as unjust.  Yet in some ways we are not that far beyond the Solonic model.  The last U.S. state to end property requirements for voting did not dispense with them until 1856.5  In Prussia and many other parts of Europe, one's economic position dramatically affected the quantitative power of one's vote until 1918.6  And of course the influence of big business and wealthy individuals on the political process today remains large.

How did Solon's reforms affect society's third main domain, the realm of cultural life (which includes what we today refer to as education, science, religion, art, news media, language, and ethnic styles and traditions)?  Solon exempted only Athenians from slavery.  To be an Athenian was essentially a cultural category, one defined by membership and birth into the Athenian ethnic community. It was believed that being part of that culture entitled the Athenian to the political rights in Solon's constitution.  In that respect Athenians fused cultural life with the political rights-state.  Another name for that particular species of mingling between culture and the state is nationalism.  In several parts of the world today, nationalism is resurgent. 

Louis Comfort Tiffany, 1848-1933. Detail, Port of Piraeus, Greece


















Nationalism is an often misguided but sometimes understandable reaction against violent and non-violent attempts by various large global forces to establish a dominant monoculture of one or another type over the whole earth.  But nationalism, which means nationality or ethnicity fused with state power, tends toward international conflict and holds back the full development of the individual.  The individual spark in each person radiates universal potential that transcends every national provincialism.  So if not by means of nationalism, how then are pressures toward global monoculture to be resisted? Multiculturalism, despite its strengths, has not always been sufficiently vigilant toward monocultural movements pushing one or another kind of totalitarianism.

It would seem prudent, in any case, to do everything possible to make culture, education, and the free life of the mind and spirit more independent of economic and political power and administration.  Every form of statist nationalism, and for that matter any form of religion that rejects the distinction between what belongs "to God" and what belongs "to Caesar," between what belongs to religion and what to the state, seems bound to lead to unfortunate outcomes.  

Support Educational Freedom: Four Small Steps You Can Take
  • donate to the Avalon Initiative, here;
  • watch this thirty-second video by Martin Luther King, III in support of Florida's tax credit scholarship program:
  • watch the minute-and-a-half-long video explanation below.  It should be added that tax credit scholarship laws can be set up in such a way that corporations and individuals get their tax bills reduced by the amount those same corporations and individuals donate to non-profit scholarship organizations, which organizations then can enable poor and middle class families to have freedom of choice among independent schools for children K-12.
  • call your senator and representative, and if s/he is not available, ask for the staffer who handles educational issues. Say that you would like to see a generous scholarship tax credit policy become law in your state, so that poor and middle class families can have real educational freedom to choose among independent schools.  


1 Thomas R. Martin, Ancient Greece: From Prehistoric to Hellenistic Times (New Haven: Yale UP, 2000), 84.↩
2 Sarah B. Pomeroy, Stanley M. Burstein, Walter Donlan and Jennifer Tolbert Roberts, Ancient Greece: A Political, Social, and Cultural History (New York: Oxford UP, 1999), 167.↩
3 Ibid., 166.↩
4 Martin, Ancient Greece: From Prehistoric to Hellenistic Times, 85; Pomeroy et al., Ancient Greece: A Political, Social, and Cultural History, 167. ↩
5 Stanley L. Engerman and Kenneth L. Sokoloff, "The Evolution of Suffrage Institutions in the New World" (2005), 16, accessed May 19, 2016.↩
6 Robert J. Goldstein, Political Repression in 19th Century Europe (New York: Routledge, 1983), 11, accessed May 19, 2016, ↩

Sunday, May 15, 2016

Was Hitler Present When Thule Society Members Attacked Steiner? Part 2

Jean Lepautre, detail from Hippolytus and
the Sea Monster
, published 1676





















HITLER was in Munich on May 15, 1922.  In the first post here on this subject, that date was not entirely beyond doubt.  The present post will show that it can be taken as reliable.  Hitler thus may have been present and somehow connected with the attack on Rudolf Steiner at Munich's Four Seasons Hotel on that date. Hitler and his paramilitary retinue had already been involved in political violence on more one occasion. That he might have been present at the attack on Steiner or connected with it is not something that seems to have been considered previously. Certainly extremists on the right had it in for Steiner because of his 1921 campaign to make Upper Silesia autonomous rather than part of Germany.

Part 1 in this series of posts recounted some of the details of the attack on Steiner and reproduced some of Hitler's published comments of 1921, in which Hitler referred to Steiner's social threefolding idea as "one of the many completely Jewish methods of destroying the peoples’ normal state of mind."

As to Hitler's location on May 15, 1922, Part 1 could only determine that Hitler was in Munich on May 13, and that he might not have left for a trip to Berlin until the 17th. After that post went up, however, Paul Bruppacher, a chronicler of Hitler's life, was contacted in the hope that he could more definitely pinpoint Hitler's whereabouts on the 15th.  Here is a translation of Mr. Bruppacher's reply:
Thank you for your inquiry.

On 14 May 1922 Hitler was in Munich. Activity unknown.
On 15 May 1922 Hitler was in Munich. Activity unknown.
On 16 May 1922 Hitler rides by car via Nürnberg and Bayreuth to Berneck.
On 17 May 1922 Hitler rides by car from Berneck via Leipzig to Berlin.

This information comes from the just published Hitler: The Itinerary, Volume 1, by Harald Sandner.

I hope to have served you with this information and remain

With friendly greetings,

Paul Bruppacher
Hitler: The Itinerary is not available in English. Some details in German about the book can be seen at Amazon, here. 

Was the 33-year-old Hitler, who for less than a year had been the leader of the Nazi Party, in some way involved in the attack on Steiner in Munich on May 15, 1922? Hitler was already somewhat well-known, so presumably he would not have participated in such an attack himself. But might he have been somehow behind it? If historians out there can rule this out or offer evidence on the probabilities, your thoughts would be appreciated.   

UPDATE: It turns out that in the 1920s, Hitler lived about six blocks from the Munich Four Seasons Hotel. Here is a Google Earth photo showing the two buildings:


This does not mean Hitler had anything to do with the attack, of course.

It has also just come to the attention of this site that one of the witnesses to the attack, Walter Beck, found a dagger had been dropped on the stage at some point during the melee. Confirmation that Beck actually wrote about finding a dagger is currently being pursued. If Beck did write of it, that would reinforce the impression that the attack was an assassination attempt. Political murders were not especially unusual during the Weimar Republic. 

Thursday, March 31, 2016

Everlasting Contentment? Nah. Let's do something.

Xu Yang, Everlasting Contentment, Handscroll dated 1773, 
ink and color on paper, jade core roller, Yale University Art Gallery













THE name of the beautiful work of art above, Everlasting Contentment, suggests something almost the opposite of social threefolding.  Rudolf Steiner:
The ‘social question’ is.... an integral part of modern civilization which has come to stay, and as such will have to be resolved anew for each moment in the world's historical development.... Just as a satiated organism experiences hunger again after a period of time, so the social organism passes from order to disorder. A food which permanently stills hunger does not exist; neither does a universal social panacea.
-- from the Preface to the 1920 edition of Toward Social Renewal: Basic Issues of the Social Question

It may be worthwhile to recall that social threefolding has been advancing gradually in various ways for thousands of years (in the column to the left, see the second heading down from the top, "Social Threefolding: Historical Examples and Current Trends"). When one is aware of that history and has an overview of threefolding dynamics and processes (in the column to the left, see the heading at the top, "An Overview of Rudolf Steiner's Social Ideas and Some Results"), it does not require much of a leap to imagine those processes developing for a long time to come.

A threefold social order is indeed not the kind of thing that can happen all at once.  Social life is infinitely complex, and threefolding by its very nature must always remain incomplete and ongoing.  In that it is like art or science. Thus it is a mistake to speak about it as some of Steiner's students have done, when they have suggested it "failed" in 1919 or 1920.  It is true that Steiner and his colleagues could not advance the process as much as they had dared to hope.  But since the 1920s, although it has regressed in some places and times, on the whole the process has arguably continued to advance.  We have the power to help it progress further.  

Take Action

For example we can help at least three already-existing major reform movements that work in this direction even though the leaders of those movements have probably never heard of threefolding. One might consider assisting organizations such as 

1) Transparency International and The Sunlight Foundation, which seek to strengthen the boundary between money and politics by working for greater transparency in government;  

2) B-Lab, which works with remarkable effectiveness to advance cooperative, transparent, socially responsible forms of capitalism, the kind that both profits and heals communities.  That form of economic life seems most likely to minimize unholy alliances between economic interests and the state and to maintain the distinction between economy and state;  

3) Step Up for Students, a Florida non-profit that distributes scholarships that make it possible for families with limited economic resources to choose an independent, non-government school for their children.  Step Up thus enhances the independence of education vis-a-vis both economic and political power.  Funding comes largely from Florida's extensive tax credit scholarship policy.  This video explains tax credit scholarships in less than two minutes.   This 2015 report explains and grades 16 U.S. states' tax credit scholarship programs, including how well they prevent the government from interfering with independent education and parental choice.  When well designed and implemented, scholarship tax credit policies appear to be the most effective current means of increasing educational freedom and insulating it from political and economic interests.  One could learn more about scholarship tax credits and then make polite phone calls (which are orders of magnitude more effective than email) to senators and representatives to ask them to support implementation or expansion of the policy in one's state.  If they are not available to speak, one might ask for the staffer who deals with education issues.

Until next time...

Tuesday, March 29, 2016

Education, Business, and the State: Part 2


IN THE last post we noted that some observers of K-12 schooling oppose for-profit businesses running public schools, while other observers emphasize trying to get government out of education.  Kristin Rawls' "Who is Profiting from Charters? The Big Bucks behind Charter School Secrecy, Financial Scandal and Corruption," is a clear case of the first approach.  For example, about a third of the way through her piece, she writes that
Gary Moriello, an educator since 1970 and Chicago principal between 1987 and 2007, tells AlterNet of an alarming experience visiting a Chicago charter school in what he calls a "notorious housing project on the near North side." The school occupied what looked on the outside like a nice, shiny new building, but it wasn't really equipped to serve students properly.  Why?  The private company that had provided the construction had no real stake in serving students or making education better. Moriello remembers:
As soon as I went inside, I could see that it was built on the cheap.  There was no gym; students just had to go outside throughout the winter.  There was no lunchroom. Instead, tables were set up in a hallway, and lunches were brought in from outside the school.
It's no surprise that for-profit companies, which are motivated solely by maximizing profit, might want to keep overhead costs as low as possible.
The Cato Institute, on the other hand, notes problems with government control of schooling. For example,
government schooling often forces citizens into political combat. Different families have different priorities on topics ranging from academics and the arts to questions of morality and religion. No single school can possibly reflect the wide range of mutually exclusive views on these fundamental subjects. In a market-based education system, parents can select the school most closely aligned with their priorities. By contrast, when these questions are decided through a political system, such as elected school boards, parents with differing views must struggle against each other to have the school reflect their views. Inevitably, some parents will lose that struggle. To add insult to injury, all citizens are forced to pay for the government-run schools through their taxes, even when those schools are antagonistic toward their most deeply held values.
Other critics of government schooling observe that the "selection" of books and curricula necessarily entails censorship of other books and curricula -- that public schooling thus depends on government censorship determined by political bodies such as school board majorities.  Partly on that basis, Stephen Arons, Professor Emeritus of Legal Studies at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, points out in his book Compelling Belief that insofar as political bodies control the formation of belief, they significantly undermine the First Amendment's freedom of expression of belief.  Arons concludes that the First Amendment requires a separation of school and state, and that the state should continue to pay for education but stop calling the tune.  Every family, not just those that have economic resources, should be able to choose from among a range of independent schools, he argues.

If one is non-partisan, one might well conclude that neither the state, which tends to stifle teachers' and parents' cultural and spiritual freedom, nor business corporations legally bound to prioritize shareholder profits, should be controlling or running K-12 education.  Is there a way past both Scylla and Charybdis? 

In the The Social Mission of Waldorf Education, Gary Lamb, co-director of the Hawthorne Valley Center for Social Research, presents a way, summed up in the book's subtitle:  Independent, Privately Funded, and Accessible to All.

It will soon be possible to find out in person how Lamb envisions getting there.  He will be one of the panelists at an April 30th conference in Redhook, NY:  Enough Already! Saving the Soul of Education.

Stay tuned.

Monday, March 28, 2016

Education, Business, and the State: Part 1

Allessandro Allori, Scylla and Charybdis, 1575, Florence

Strait of Messina, between Scylla and Charybdis

IN THINKING about education, business, and the state, we may be reminded of how Homer's Odysseus narrowly escapes death twice when passing through the Messina straits.  First Scylla, the six-headed monster, formerly a nymph, devours six of Odysseus' best men and nearly destroys his ship.  Later, Odysseus barely escapes Charybdis, the terrible whirlpool (who was also previously a nymph) on the opposite side of the straits.

Rudolf Steiner, in speaking of Odysseus, described his ship and his men as images of the various forces of the human soul struggling to avoid falling under the sway of spiritual forces of an extreme character.  In his wooden sculpture, The Representative of Humanity, Steiner portrayed Christ maintaining balance between two extreme beings:  Lucifer above, and Ahriman below.  Once, Steiner said that Charybdis, the whirlpool, was an image of Lucifer, and the swirling passions and desires.  The six-headed Scylla, chained to the rocks, was an image of Ahriman, who in Steiner's accounts seeks to chain human imagination entirely to the physical world.

In discussions today about how to reform education for children in the U.S., one side sees disaster in letting for-profit businesses run so-called public charter schools.  Another side of the discussion sees the destructive aspects of allowing government control of schools to continue.  Both sides have a point.  Is there a way past both Scylla and Charybdis?  Part 2 is here.