Showing posts with label educational freedom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label educational freedom. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 3, 2016

Strangely Good Conversations: Part 1

Michelangelo, detail from The Libyan Sibyl, c.1511




















IN THE little town of Redhook in upstate New York, at the Avalon Initiative’s April 30th “Enough Already” conference, the theme was "saving the soul" of education.  From what?  From a hostile takeover by politicians allied with self-interested technology- and testing companies.  That aspect of the conference was discussed in a previous post.  This post concerns a friendly conversation the writer chanced to strike up there with a young woman.  She works as a teacher in a public school (which in the United States means a state-run school).

In the course of the conversation, the teacher was asked why families that possess economic resources should be the only ones that have the option of choosing from among independent, non-government schools for their children? She seemed genuinely troubled by the question.

The book Compelling Belief: The Culture of American Schooling, by liberal legal scholar Stephen Arons of the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, was then mentioned to her along with one of the main points Arons makes:  public schooling in the U.S. entails censorship of the educational preferences of various intellectual, cultural, scientific, spiritual, and racial minorities, because most public schools are controlled by political majorities.  In making decisions about curricula and teachers, for example, local school board majorities select some educational content and policies, and by the same token necessarily censor other educational content. Hearing this said, the teacher did not deny the point, and again seemed troubled.

Odilon Redon, Reflection, 1900-1905















In a hopeful tone, she asked whether somehow the situation was all for the best. Could it not be a good thing, she asked, that people are compelled into a common curriculum? And anyway, she continued, why must people vote on such things? Why cannot school boards work on the basis of consensus instead?

At times the tone of her questions made her sound almost as if she were begging God, and not just the people present, to provide some escape from the dilemma that had been presented to her. It appeared that ideals she valued and that she had been accustomed to link with public schooling were at stake.

Whether God answered or not, the teacher heard from her earthly conversation partner that it might indeed be wonderful if school boards could work on the basis of consensus rather than by voting, but that unfortunately, in practice people in most school districts and other political venues have strong disagreements about something as fundamental as educational content and methods, and thus end up voting on educational matters, not working by consensus. As for those who are intellectually, spiritually, or otherwise in the minority, escape from the majority-imposed educational culture is only possible if a family has the resources to move to another school district or pay for an independent school. (Among topics left undiscussed were problems with charter schools, such as the politically constrained kinds of educational choices they permit, or the corrupt behavior of some of the business interests involved.)

Van Gogh, Still Life with French Novels and a Rose, 1887















The teacher again wondered, with a hint of yearning in her voice, if it was not somehow for the best that people are kept within a unified system. In reply, she was asked why people then do not vote on which newspapers can be sold in a particular neighborhood, or which religions can be practiced.

It was then suggested to her that schooling is essentially like art, religion, science, and the media, and that it belongs, in other words, in the sphere of culture, where freedom and each family's individual choice should rule, but where political majorities (and business interests) should not. An image that Gary Lamb of the Avalon Initiative projected on a screen at the conference thus came into the conversation. In the image, culture appeared as a third social domain with its own boundary distinct from those of the polity and the economy, even as the three domains partly overlapped: 

Image from the Avalon Initiative website

There was not enough time during the conversation to consider how the independence of the three sectors needs to be there not merely for its own sake, but precisely so the three can influence one another: it is only their autonomy, if it has been sufficiently established, that can allow them to check, balance, and correct one another as they develop and change.  Insofar as any one of the three centers takes over and compromises the autonomy of one or both of the other two, however, the three domains begin to lose the capacity to mutually correct, conflicts of interest emerge, unhealthy social forms grow, and social evolution gets dammed up.

In thinking about cultural life, one could do worse than to remember what Stephen Arons pointed out a long time ago:  the U.S. First Amendment's freedom of expression of belief is significantly undermined if the formation of belief is controlled by political majorities.  Therefore neither the latter nor economic interests should organize or control education.

In the memory of the writer, the teacher's conscientious fair-mindedness during the conversation will live on as an example to live up to.  

Support Educational Freedom: Four Small Steps You Can Take
  • donate to the Avalon Initiative, here;
  • watch this thirty-second video by Martin Luther King, III in support of Florida's tax credit scholarship program:
  • watch the minute-and-a-half-long video explanation below.  It should be added that tax credit scholarship laws can be set up in such a way that corporations and individuals get their tax bills reduced by the amount those same corporations and individuals donate to non-profit scholarship organizations, which organizations then can enable poor and middle class families to have freedom of choice among independent schools for children K-12.
  • call your senator and representative, and if s/he is not available, ask for the staffer who handles educational issues. Say that you would like to see a generous scholarship tax credit policy become law in your state, so that poor and middle class families can have real educational freedom to choose among independent schools. 
 *            *            *
The next post might report briefly on a conversation that afforded the pleasure of listening to Michael Lapointe, an economics researcher with the Avalon Initiative. At times when he spoke, it felt in some ways a bit as if one had walked into the film My Dinner with Andre.

Monday, May 2, 2016

Dangers to the Soul of Education: Big Business and the State

Konstantin Gorbatov, Harbor in Naples, 1930














SATURDAY, April 30, in Redhook, about 100 miles due north of New York City, teachers, professors, and organizers came together with about 40 attendees at the Avalon Initiative's "Enough Already" conference. The purpose? To "save the soul" of education.

Images from the
Avalon Initiative
website
At first it was slightly disorienting, to this attendee at any rate, to find Gary Lamb and Patrice Maynard, who are both supporters of Rudolf Steiner's social ideas, organizing a conference at which advocates for government-run public schooling were prominent among those invited to speak.

True, Steiner himself held that every child had a right to an education.  But he also thought that a healthy educational system could only be based on freedom and choice for teachers and parents.  To avoid eventual social disaster it was essential, he maintained, that education be made independent of the state yet available to all children regardless of their financial resources.  So how did it come to pass that of the seven speakers the organizers had at the conference, four had no noticeable problem with government-run education per se?  For example, there was Marla Kilfoyle, Executive Director of the Badass Teachers Association, a national activist organization "dedicated to stopping the privatization of our public school system," according to a sheet handed out at the conference.

Paul Gauguin, Bathing, Dieppe, 1885

The solution to the little conundrum soon became evident. The two sides were in agreement with respect to the main purpose of the conference: to resist an alliance between the government, educational testing companies, and technology companies.  That business/government alliance, speakers said, was seeking to advance corporate interests and politicians' ambitions by establishing an increasingly pervasive control over the education of children and thus over all the money involved in schooling.

Some of the presenters outlined how technology- and testing companies, driven by profit rather than by solid educational research, had envisioned turning public schooling throughout the country into something like a vast computer game programmed around Common Core testing standards or the like. Conference attendees were informed that some $8 billion a year was being spent to bring technology into the schools, and that the amount would quickly double.

That is indeed a large market over which companies can be expected to compete hungrily while seeking convenient policies and legislation from politicians, who are too willing to go along in order to get the corporate money needed to fund expensive election campaigns. The dream some of the technology companies have expressed, attendees were told, envisions making human teachers more or less redundant, but retraining them as something like data consultants for pupils. Children would be working increasingly with computers, which would be programmed to assess educational progress every five minutes.

Farmers Market #19, Melon Man, 2013,
courtesy of the artist, Julie Ford Oliver















The massive testing regimes more and more being pushed into schools by profit-driven business and the federal government, some of the speakers said, have led to pushback from teachers and parents outraged at the pressures being placed on children. One panelist told of how, in order to take some of the stress off children, time limits to complete the state-mandated tests had in some cases been extended by several hours.  But instead of taking pressure off, the change sometimes made things worse: some students, apparently partly to save teachers from losing their jobs, were spending six hours per day for three consecutive days taking the tests, going over and over them, only to end up in tears when the tests finally had to be taken away. 

Also noted at the conference was how mandated state testing in schools tended to centralize the decision over what is "worth knowing" and what is the "right answer" to every question, whereas schooling should do more to raise children capable of imagining new questions and new answers. Students should not be taught to conform to a brave new world molded by an ever more pervasive testing regime set up by politicians and businessmen.

Odilon Redon, The Barque, early 1900s

































Gary Lamb, Patrice Maynard, and all the others who organized this conference or spoke there deserve tremendous thanks for all the incisive presentations, as well as for the new alliances forged and the convivial conversations had among the various and interesting participants.

The Avalon Initiative's "Enough Already" conference may yet be the subject of another post here.  

Take Action for Educational Freedom: Two Things You Can Do
  • Support tax credit scholarships: politely call (far more effective than emailing) your senator or representative (if s/he is not available, ask to speak to the staffer who handles educational issues) and explain that you support tax credit scholarship policies that allow individuals and corporations to receive tax credits in exchange for donating funds to non-profit scholarship organizations that then can make scholarships available to poor and middle-class families to use at a school of the family's choice. 

*               *               *

Below, from the Avalon Initiative website, are images of, and blurbs about, the presenters who came to the "Enough Already" conference.  Jane Ried of the Aurora Waldorf School is not shown, but also played an important part.

Images and blurbs taken from the Avalon Initiative website

Thursday, March 31, 2016

Everlasting Contentment? Nah. Let's do something.

Xu Yang, Everlasting Contentment, Handscroll dated 1773, 
ink and color on paper, jade core roller, Yale University Art Gallery













THE name of the beautiful work of art above, Everlasting Contentment, suggests something almost the opposite of social threefolding.  Rudolf Steiner:
The ‘social question’ is.... an integral part of modern civilization which has come to stay, and as such will have to be resolved anew for each moment in the world's historical development.... Just as a satiated organism experiences hunger again after a period of time, so the social organism passes from order to disorder. A food which permanently stills hunger does not exist; neither does a universal social panacea.
-- from the Preface to the 1920 edition of Toward Social Renewal: Basic Issues of the Social Question

It may be worthwhile to recall that social threefolding has been advancing gradually in various ways for thousands of years (in the column to the left, see the second heading down from the top, "Social Threefolding: Historical Examples and Current Trends"). When one is aware of that history and has an overview of threefolding dynamics and processes (in the column to the left, see the heading at the top, "An Overview of Rudolf Steiner's Social Ideas and Some Results"), it does not require much of a leap to imagine those processes developing for a long time to come.

A threefold social order is indeed not the kind of thing that can happen all at once.  Social life is infinitely complex, and threefolding by its very nature must always remain incomplete and ongoing.  In that it is like art or science. Thus it is a mistake to speak about it as some of Steiner's students have done, when they have suggested it "failed" in 1919 or 1920.  It is true that Steiner and his colleagues could not advance the process as much as they had dared to hope.  But since the 1920s, although it has regressed in some places and times, on the whole the process has arguably continued to advance.  We have the power to help it progress further.  

Take Action

For example we can help at least three already-existing major reform movements that work in this direction even though the leaders of those movements have probably never heard of threefolding. One might consider assisting organizations such as 

1) Transparency International and The Sunlight Foundation, which seek to strengthen the boundary between money and politics by working for greater transparency in government;  

2) B-Lab, which works with remarkable effectiveness to advance cooperative, transparent, socially responsible forms of capitalism, the kind that both profits and heals communities.  That form of economic life seems most likely to minimize unholy alliances between economic interests and the state and to maintain the distinction between economy and state;  

3) Step Up for Students, a Florida non-profit that distributes scholarships that make it possible for families with limited economic resources to choose an independent, non-government school for their children.  Step Up thus enhances the independence of education vis-a-vis both economic and political power.  Funding comes largely from Florida's extensive tax credit scholarship policy.  This video explains tax credit scholarships in less than two minutes.   This 2015 report explains and grades 16 U.S. states' tax credit scholarship programs, including how well they prevent the government from interfering with independent education and parental choice.  When well designed and implemented, scholarship tax credit policies appear to be the most effective current means of increasing educational freedom and insulating it from political and economic interests.  One could learn more about scholarship tax credits and then make polite phone calls (which are orders of magnitude more effective than email) to senators and representatives to ask them to support implementation or expansion of the policy in one's state.  If they are not available to speak, one might ask for the staffer who deals with education issues.

Until next time...